AITA for rejecting my ex's offer to do joint Christmas' with our son?

A woman divorced her serial-cheating husband four years ago, discovering he’d had a long-term girlfriend who got pregnant during proceedings. They share custody of their 8-year-old son, splitting holidays peacefully via app.

Now single-dadding his 3-year-old affair child after the mom bailed, the ex proposed “joint Christmases” so both boys grow up close—and she could step in as a mom figure for the little one. She firmly declined, citing lingering betrayal and no desire for attachment. Ex and his mom ambushed her in public, guilting her about the boy’s lack of a mother and accusing her of driving brothers apart.

‘AITA for rejecting my ex’s offer to do joint Christmas’ with our son?’

The marriage ended painfully:

I have an 8 year old son with my ex. We separated almost 4 years ago when I learned he was sleeping around throughout most of our marriage and he...

Advertisement

Their son was born during the divorce. Ex and I share custody and split Christmas every year. We do all our communication through an app. Or we're supposed to anyway.....

Hints of pressure built:

Whenever I see ex's mom, who lives 20 minutes from me, she always mentions how she wishes I was the mom to her other grandson and how sad it is...

Advertisement

I was always a little suspicious of comments like that because what good do they do? It made me aware that he and his family might want me to be...

The proposal came via text:

Last week ex texted me and said he was thinking about the future. How he has two boys and how he wants his son to grow up with memories of...

Advertisement

So how about we stop with the conflict and come together every Christmas and I could get to know his son more and be part of his life and we...

He brought up how our son isn't really as close to his son as he wanted him to be and that his son smiles whenever he sees me and would...

Advertisement

To sum it up he wanted us to do joint Christmas' going forward and for me to be in his son's life. I ignored the part about his son and...

Ex did not leave it there and he tried to convince me by using the "I know you hate Christmas when our son isn't with you" and he's not wrong....

Advertisement

I also do not want his son to become attached to me or seek a mom figure in me.. So I said no and no again when he didn't give...

Public confrontation followed:

I saw ex and his mom Wednesday when I was grabbing some groceries while my son was at his best friend's house. They came right up to me and said...

Advertisement

His mom again mentioned how sad it is that his son doesn't have a mom and ex told me I am going to come between the boys if our son...

He told me to do better and stop being such an ass to him and his son. His mom was like "be the amazing mom we know you are". She...

Advertisement

This reeks of manipulation disguised as “for the kids.” The ex’s serial cheating destroyed trust—expecting fake family holidays ignores that wound. Pressuring her into mom duties for an affair child is entitlement at its peak; boundaries protect everyone, including preventing unhealthy attachments.

Sibling closeness develops naturally during dad’s custody time, not forced events with a resentful ex. Grandma’s guilt trips enable denial of consequences. Co-parenting works via app for a reason—stick to it, document ambushes.

Compassion for the innocent boy is fair, but she’s not obligated to fill voids created by others’ choices. Therapy for ex/family might help process abandonment; she prioritizes her healing and son’s stability—smart move.

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Unanimous NTA—community roasts the audacity, spots manipulation, and applauds her boundaries.

Many highlight the cheating origin:

moew4974 − Lemme get this straight. You were married. Living a life together. Had a child. Then you find out your husband is a cheating sleaze for almost the entirety...

You divorce him, she gets pregnant, and then ghosts him and their child. And yet he wants some sort of compassion and connection from you 'for the boys sake'? Do...

Advertisement

On the off chance I'm overcomplicating or oversimplifying things, please let me know. Okay, where do I start? 1. His mom- Response: "Yeah, I AM an amazing mom. I am...

And he chose to cheat for a vast majority of our relationship. He chose to impregnate a woman who was just as unstable and unreliable as he was to me...

Advertisement

but the fact is that if your son had been raised with some morals and some values and could keep his d! @$ in his pants that son would have...

2. Him- "I have nothing to do with how our son sees his brother or their closeness. I've never spoken against your son or you for that matter, to our...

Advertisement

You have the life that you chose. You didn't want me when you had me, now you want a surrogate for your motherless child. I'm gonna have to pass on...

We don't have a good relationship because you ruined everything good about us with your lies and cheating. You need to own that and stop trying to make me your...

Advertisement

We will not be having holidays as a family all together. Now or ever. " You are definitely NTA here.

catskilkid − NTA What a load of BS. If his concern is the boys aren't as close as they can be, then he is not doing a good job when...

Advertisement

??!!!! If there is an issue with him communicating with the APP, DON"T communicate any other way. He made his bed (apparently others as well) and now he has to....

Several suspect ulterior motives like free childcare:

Hopeful-Chipmunk6530 − Nta. You know it won’t end with just Christmas. He’s probably looking to be able to dump his other kid on you. He gets a break from your...

Advertisement

While I do feel bad for the boy who probably wishes he had a mother present in his life, it’s never a good idea to push kids where they arent...

[Reddit User] − Your ex cheated on you, got his mistress pregnant, mistress had enough and left him and their son.

Advertisement

Now your ex wants you to play "mommy" to a child conceived while he was married to you? ?? I'll give him one thing, he has the balls of a...

Beautiful-Report58 − NTA When will it stop, with his 3rd kid, 4th? How many compromises are you supposed to make on his behalf?

Advertisement

You are under no obligation to accommodate their weird requests. In fact, don’t consider it any further, since it’s a resolved issue for you. It’s so tiring when people think...

HUNGWHITEBOI25 − NTA Just to be clear, your ex’s mother DOES know that your ex cheated on you right? If she does that means she thinks that you should be...

Advertisement

Disastrous_Cress_701 − NTA Dude doesn't like being a full time daddy. I put money if you agreed to any sort of contact with the kid, it would become "can you...

" Or worse "the kids love each other, it's not fair to separate them during your weeks, 3yo should come" When he brings it up again, tell him to stop...

Advertisement

FormerRunnerAgain − NTA - he is clearly looking for child care, probably so he can get his rocks off. Stop talking to him. If he calls, don't answer, send him...

If he calls when he has his son, don't answer, text back asking is this an emergency in regards to son, otherwise you can contact me through the app. Don't...

Advertisement

If his mother continues to mettle, explain to her that you are surprised that he is suddenly so concerned about two parent families as he certainly didn't care about your...

Remind her that the mother was his affair partner and it would be very inappropriate for you to meddle in their affair.

Advertisement

Ok-Abbreviations4510 − NTA. Cut them off next time they try to bring it up. Tell them you already gave your answer and the conversation is closed then walk away/hang up/don’t...

PurpleMarsAlien − NTA It's not your fault that your cheating ex chose someone who abandoned her child to have his next child with, and it's not your responsibility to step...

Advertisement

GirlDad2023_ − That'd be a hard NO from this reader. Obviously your ex did something to chase off his wife #2, now known as the cheater wife.

But it's ridiculous to even ASK you to do a joint Christmas. I'm sure the former MIL means well but she needs to talk to the childs actual mom instead...

Advertisement

PuddleLilacAgain − NTA. While I feel for the ex's girlfriend's baby, I have to question his motivations. As a serial cheater, he may be narcissistic and doesn't want to take...

Why can't he be a single father? The child won't die without you being his mother. I feel badly for the child, but you are not responsible for this mess....

Advertisement

[Reddit User] − NTA What in the Hallmark holiday movie are they hoping will happen? You'll make eyes over the ham and fall in love again?

His 3 year old will take your hand and call you "mommy" and your heart will grow three sizes? What isn't fair is volunteering someone for a role and then...

Advertisement

NUredditNU − Tell his mom to mind HER business for crying out loud. How about she worry about the cheater she raised as a mother instead of what kind of...

ThatsItImOverThis − NTA He totally wants you to be replacement mom. Don’t be fooled, which it sounds like you’re not, this is all a manipulation to try and get you...

Advertisement

Cheaters don’t get to rewrite history into blended bliss after blowing up lives. This mom owes zero holidays or maternal energy to consequences of betrayal—protecting her peace models strength for her son.

Ever faced ex-family guilt trips post-breakup? Would you ever consider joint events with an affair child involved? Weigh in below!

WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS STORY?
Loading poll…